Butter Me Up (14.0% ABV)

American Fifth White Rum, Butterscotch Vodka, Faygo Creme Soda

1 oz. American Fifth White Rum
1 oz. Butterscotch Vodka
3 oz. Faygo Creme Soda

Build American Fifth Rum and Butterscotch Vodka in iced shaker. Shake and strain into iced highball. Top with Faygo Creme Soda. Garnish with caramel drizzle.

May not be available in the tasting room.
Check our current menu for our tasting room selections.

Share This Recipe:

More Cocktail Recipes

I’m Sprung (17.4% ABV)

American Fifth Gin, cranberry juice, house-made fruit simple syrup, fresh squeezed lemon juice, egg white

Smokey Joe (16.9% ABV)

American Fifth Bourbon, house-made simple syrup, apple cider, sage, smoked apple wood, Cocktail Experiment Chicory Bitters

Peep This (26.0% ABV)

American Fifth Cherry Liqueur, American Fifth Bourbon Creame, marshmallow fluff, house-made fruit simple syrup

You must be over 21 to visit this website.

Are 21 or older?